A critique of the boasian paradigm basing his analysis on kroeber s the superorganic 191749. Alfred kroeber and the concept of the superorganic issues in. The traditional perspectives of anthropology and sociology should merge into a temporary condominium leading to a differentiated but ultimately collaborative attack on problems in. Kroeber included material from the article in his textbook anthropology. Edited and with an introduction by alex golub first edition, 11 october, 20. He was also the first professor appointed to the department of. The superorganic in american cultural geography james s. Some have compared it to durkheim, the majority to boas.
One of these pairs of ideas with which our world has been laboring for some two thousand years is expressed in the words body and soul. In kroeber s ideas of the superorganic, how does he conceptualize the individual. The superorganic, or culture, in kroebers view, was not only distinct and. The superorganic mode of explanation in cultural geography rei fies the notion of. Sauer, made berkeley the defacto center of this school to such a degree that in the field of cultural geography, the superorganic is sometimes called the berkeley school. The organic level is thought to have emerged from the inorganic and the superorganic from the organic level. Kroeber found the requisite milieu in new york, and did not, in fact, visit germany. Open library is an initiative of the internet archive, a 501c3 nonprofit, building a digital library of internet sites and other cultural artifacts in digital form. Historical particularism was a dominant trend in anthropology during the first half of the twentieth century. Pdf alfred kroeber and the concept of the superorganic. Half bloods, he added, are likely to merge into the white. The superorganic by alfred louis kroeber goodreads. The last it is not that kroeber was ignorant of culture in appears to be the origin.
What contemporary ideas did tylor build on, and what contemporary ideas did tylor. One of the achievements of the historical particularists was that they succeeded in excluding racism from anthropology. Recently that position, methodological individualism, has been challenged on. The nineteenthcentury evolutionists explained cultural similarities and differences by classifying societies into. Originally published in 1917 in american anthropologist, the article drew important. A superorganism or supraorganism the latter is less frequently used but more etymologically correct is a group of synergetically interacting organisms of the same species. Alfred kroebers the superorganic is a classic of anthropological theory. Lo superorganico kroeber pdf the term superorganic was probably first used by the early sociologist herbert of the time, alfred kroeber and edward sapir, in the. The university of kansas prohibits discrimination on the basis of race, color, ethnicity, religion, sex, national origin, age, ancestry, disability, status as a veteran, sexual orientation, marital status, parental status, gender identity, gender expression and genetic information in the universitys programs and activities. Alfred kroeber s the superorganic is a classic of anthropological theory. It is some such irritation that seems to have served as the emotional impetus of dr. Race, language, culture, psychology, and prehistory.
June but to kroeber, the superorganic was actually what made anthropology a science with its subject matter being the universals and regularities of human. Contributor jstor language english volume 19 the superorganic is an article from american anthropologist, volume 19. This theory of culture was outlined by anthropologists alfred kroeber and robert lowie during the first quarter of the twentieth century, later elaborated by leslie. Tylors concept of culture and spencers of the social as superorganic were important attempts to formulate such a sphere. Kroeber s very interesting discussion of the superorganic. Kuzemkino we can help you if you came here to download pdf. Kroeber s biggest contribution is the reformulation of spencers concept of the superorganic which kroeber used to analyze the notion of culture. It is also important to emphasize that in asking this question, kroeber clearly sees the importance of biological anthropology and human kroebed history to cultural anthropology. He feels that he deals with an entirely different order of phenomena, that direct comparison between the two groups of disciplines is to be ruled out of court. The superorganic is another way of describing and understanding culture or the sociocultural system. Originally published in 1917 in american anthropologist, the article drew important responses from edward sapir and alexander goldenweiser.
Which of his peers boass other students most blatantly disagreed with him. Like kroeber they have called in a force he calls the superorganic to account for. The following person has been designated to handle inquiries. The idea of the superorganic is associated with alfred kroeber, an american anthropologist writing in the first half of the twentieth century. June but to kroeber, the superorganic was actually.
Alfred kroeber the superorganic and style patterns alfred kroeber 18761960 received his doctorate under franz boas, at boas at columbia university in 1901, basing his dissertation on his field work among the arapaho. Kroeber parted from boas on the question of the german state. They add that if one thinks of culture as patterned, the reference is primarily to culture in the parti tive sense rather than general culture. Kroeber superorganico pdf however, in the theoretical sense, kroeber s biggest contribution is the re formulation of spencers concept of the superorganic which. Culture versus biology in the thought of franz boas and alfred l. But kroebers formulation of the superorganic was, according to gamst and norbeck 1976. Publication date 19170401 publisher american anthropologist. Alfred louis kroeber was an american cultural anthropologist.
A community of synergetically interacting organisms of different species is called a holobiont. This theory of culture was outlined by anthropologists alfred kroeber and robert lowie during the first quarter of the twentieth century, later elaborated by leslie white, and passed on to carl sauer and a number of his students at berkeley. If other minds want to publish in the series, then they can do so too who knows what projects they may want to cook up. Kroeber s and there are three basic levels of reality. The superorganic by alfred kroeber, edited and with an introduction by alex golub 2. Basing his analysis on kroebers the superorganic 1917 and eighteen. The superorganic, or kroebers hidden agenda michel verdon.
Kroebers the superorganic 1917 stands as the first extreme statement. He spent most of his career in at the university of california, berkeley, where he. The superorganic mode of explanation in cultural geography rei fies the notion of culture assigning it ontological status and causative power. The superorganic, or kroebers hidden agenda michel. Pdf culture the use and abuse of an anthropological concept. Kroeber s the superorganic 1917 stands as the first extreme statement of cultural holism. Lo superorganico kroeber pdf the term superorganic was probably first used by the early sociologist herbert of the time, alfred kroeber and edward sapir, in the american. Allan hanson despite proposals by kroeber and others that society and culture represent a distinct level of reality, the prevailing opinion has been that they are abstractions from the behavior of individuals.
556 1248 1332 1337 850 345 737 1167 1456 435 820 1068 757 293 205 1085 56 201 934 452 562 1008 370 657 523 1330 102 753 1149 1490 864 898 698 1297 337 389 899 1182 632 1073 1342